794.5621/9–451

The Secretary of Defense (Marshall) to the Secretary of State

top secret

Dear Mr. Secretary: I am forwarding herewith, for whatever action your Department considers necessary, a photostatic copy of my letter to the President, dated 28 August 1951, concerning the new policy for arming Japanese-manned ships. The President approved this policy on 29 August 1951.

The Joint Chiefs of Staff have been requested to take appropriate action to implement this policy, at the appropriate time.

Faithfully yours,

G. C. Marshall
[Enclosure]
top secret

Dear Mr. President: The Joint Chiefs of Staff have recommended that I obtain your approval on the following policy respecting the arming of Japanese-manned ships. Current policy decisions of the Far Eastern Commission prohibit the arming of coastal patrol ships that are Japanese-manned. The Joint Chiefs of Staff have now informed me that the depletion of the occupation forces in Japan has created a situation in which the internal security of the islands and the security of the occupation forces may be seriously threatened.

Consequently, the Departments of State and Defense have reevaluated the political and military aspects of this new situation and have jointly agreed to a new policy which will permit the Supreme Commander for the Allied Powers (SCAP) to utilize Japanese forces adequately armed for defense and the maintenance of internal security. This new policy, which I recommend for your approval, is as follows:

“In view of the radically changed conditions and the increased need to insure the security of Japan, the Supreme Commander for the Allied Powers is authorized to establish a Japanese-manned coastal security force, organized and equipped along normal coast guard lines, composed of vessels with appropriate armament and speed, and under SCAP operational control, to be operated in waters contiguous to the Japanese islands.”

This represents the appropriate interim policy statement for the period between the signing of the Treaty of Peace with Japan and the coming into effect of the Treaty. When Japan regains her sovereignty and the right to provide for her own defense, a new United States policy, in connection with the Japanese security forces, will be appropriate.

It is the understanding of the Departments of State and Defense that the coastal security force established by SCAP would be placed under the direct operational control of American officers, and that the [Page 1331] vessels would carry armament appropriate for coast guard craft. The Secretary of State has concurred in this proposed policy statement on the understanding, which the Joint Chiefs of Staff and I confirm, that this coastal security force will be organized along normal coast guard lines; the armament and speed of the vessels will be that of normal coast guard character; the force will, in general, be constituted so as to provide no valid basis for an assumption that it is in fact the nucleus of a revived Japanese navy; and that no action will be taken looking toward the reestablishment of a Japanese navy without approval at the highest levels of this Government.

The Secretary of State has recommended, and the Joint Chiefs of Staff and I have concurred, that the proposed statement of policy be presented to you for approval with the understanding that it will not be implemented until after the signing of the Treaty of Peace with Japan. The Secretary of State has informed me that, if this proposed policy meets with your approval, he will inform certain friendly members of the Far Eastern Commission of the implementation of this action at the appropriate time.1

With great respect,

Faithfully yours,

G. C. Marshall
  1. The following note is handwritten in the margin of the original: “Approved Aug. 29, 1951 Harry S Truman”.

    The substance of the paragraph in quotations (in the letter above) was transmitted to SCAP on September 18 with the following comment:

    “In approving the foregoing policy it was concluded that you as SCAP have the authority to do this within your administrative discretion. However, prior to your taking formal action and matter becoming public knowledge State desires inform UK and certain other friendly FEC countries of proposed action. Anticipate this can be completed within 2 or 3 weeks, at which time you will be notified. In meantime suggest you proceed with informal preparations on basis strict secrecy.”

    (JCS telegram 81770 of September 18 to SCAP; copy attached to memorandum of November 27 from Mr. Allison to Mr. Webb, not printed; 894.501/11–651).