740.0011 Four Power Pact/17

Memorandum by the Secretary of State

The French Ambassador15 came in and handed me a memorandum of three pages containing comment and views of the French Government relative to the recent MacDonald and Mussolini peace and disarmament proposals. I stated that I was especially glad to have the benefit of the French viewpoint to this partial extent at least.

C[ordell] H[ull]
[Enclosure—Memorandum]16

Before receiving Mr. MacDonald and Sir John Simon, Mr. Mussolini has communicated to the French Ambassador in Rome the political pact of which he is the author. This text provides for a pledge from France, Great Britain, Germany and Italy to enter into a policy [Page 399] of collaboration for the maintenance of peace and to act in the domain of European relations so that such policy be adopted at the same time by the other powers, in the spirit of the Kellogg pact.17

  • Article Second states the principle of the possibility of the revision of treaties “as provided for in the Pact of the League of Nations18 and in a spirit of mutual comprehension and solidarity of interests involved”.
  • Article Third stipulates that the equality of rights granted Germany concerning armaments will be effective, but that Germany can attain this equality only by degrees and after an agreement of the three other powers. The same disposition applies to Austria, Hungary and Bulgaria.
  • In Article Fourth, the contracting powers engage themselves to adopt as soon as possible a common policy in economic as well as in political matters.

The British delegates, on the 21st of March, have informed the President of the Council and Mr. Paul-Boncour of the conversation they had with M. Mussolini. Mr. Ramsay MacDonald and Sir John Simon have not thoroughly discussed with him the substance of the plan.

However, in respect to mention made of the Article 3 of Austria and Hungary, they have pointed out the fact that there were some other countries interested and that in any case, such an agreement could not be presented to them as an accomplished fact.

The French Ministers, in reply, have emphasized the fact that, in view of the Pact of the League of Nations, of the Locarno Agreements19 and of the special agreements entered into by France with Poland and the Little Entente and the “Accord de confiance” adhered to by the European countries, it was difficult to conceive a collaboration in the form of a board of four powers, of which the interested countries would be excluded.

In the opinion of Messrs. Daladier20 and Paul-Boncour, it appears that the best way to obtain the object of Mr. Mussolini would be to consider the proposed collaboration as a collaboration of the prominent members of the Council and consequently in connection with the League of Nations.

As far as the revision of treaties and disarmament are concerned, the French ministers have emphasized the danger of having recourse to Article 19 of the Pact before the establishment of any procedure for [Page 400] its application, and of attaining the equality of rights not by a reduction but through an increase of armaments. The French Government feels obliged to stand by the declaration of November [December] 11th, 1932,21 and to connect those two questions with the question of security. Messrs. Daladier and Paul-Boncour objected to the exclusive introduction of those two questions in a general agreement of collaboration for the maintenance of peace.

In conclusion, they informed the British ministers of their intention to consult with the Governments of Belgium, Poland and of the Little Entente, and stated their conviction that this program of collaboration should be consistent with the spirit of the Pact of the League of Nations and the procedures already established in Geneva for the solution of the European problems.

  1. Paul Claudel.
  2. Copies of this memorandum were transmitted to the Ambassadors in France, Germany, and Italy and to the Chairman of the American delegation to the Disarmament Conference.
  3. Treaty for the Renunciation of War, signed at Paris, August 27, 1928, Foreign Relations, 1928, vol. i, p. 153.
  4. Treaties, Conventions, etc., Between the United States of America and Other Powers, 1910–1923 (Washington, Government Printing Office, 1923), vol. iii, p. 3336.
  5. For texts of the agreements signed at Locarno, October 16, 1925, see League of Nations Treaty Series, vol. liv, pp. 289–363.
  6. Édouard Daladier, President of the French Council of Ministers.
  7. Foreign Relations, 1932, vol. i, p. 527.